Memories of Times Past

     Although she has only appeared once in the book thus far (and only in Clarissa’s thoughts), Sally Seton further highlights the odd relationships and connections Clarissa has. First it must be acknowledged that Clarissa’s relationship with Sally is unlike any other we find in this book, and arguably the strongest. We can compare this relationship with two other important relationships in the book: Clarissa and Richard, and Clarissa and Peter. Clarissa doesn’t speak much of her husband Richard, and we can reap a lot from that. She lives with her husband everyday and yet she has nothing to say about him. We as readers can see that Clarissa doesn’t hold that much of a connection, if any connection at all with her husband. Clarissa seems to see Richard simply as a social game piece. She is his wife and he is her husband, and that is all. However, we do see a bit more of a connection between Clarissa and Peter. She talks about him very affectionately, describing him looking “awfully well” (39). But she still gets quite annoyed at him from time to time. For example, when Peter interrupts her, she says “It was like running one’s face against a granite wall in the darkness! It was shocking; it was horrible!” (35). But the way Clarissa talks of Sally is completely star-crossed. Clarissa even considers that she could’ve been in love with Sally. Every detail from appearance to attitude appeals to Clarissa, so much so that she describes not being able to take her eyes off her. 

Now, what Clarissa finds attractive about Sally is another interesting matter. The characteristic Clarissa seems to admire the most is Sally’s wildness. Sally doesn’t act like how a young lady should, cutting off the heads of flowers, reading deep literature, and running nude across the hall when she forgets her bath towel. The reasons for Clarissa’s attraction to Sally could signify the longing Clarissa has for a more adventurous, risk-taking lifestyle. Everything about Clarissa’s life screams order and class. She is wealthy, meaning she must maintain an image, and Richard was arguably the “safe” choice to marry compared to Peter. Clarissa’s inner desire to break out of her shell definitely plays a part in her attraction to Sally. 

Even though Clarissa describes Sally in such a loving and remarkable manner. Clarissa is recalling everything from her memory. Memories can be often romanticized, and through romanticization, flaws and bad qualities are usually filtered out. The more recent the memory, the more detail it contains, and the more flaws it potentially holds. Using this reasoning I suggest that Sally could be regarded highly by Clarissa because Clarissa hasn’t seen her for a long time. Further strengthening this reasoning, when Clarissa first thinks of Peter, there aren’t many flaws she points out. However, when Clarissa meets Peter in person, she is quick to get annoyed by him toying with his pocket knife. In addition, Clarissa has no interest with her husband, who she spends the most time with. 

Based on this observation, I could draw two points on human psychology. One, people tend to romanticize their past relationships and experiences, not necessarily appreciating their current ones in life. Second, some people get attracted to people with opposite traits. Interestingly, the common thread of the two points is that people get excited about what they do not have. Simply put, the grass is always greener on the other side. So, when you desire something you do not have, rethink! Are you falling into this psychological trap? 

Also writing about this topic reminded me of this song. Give it a listen! (https://youtu.be/GVwJNg4Wgq4

Comments

  1. I definitely agree that those two points about human psychology are very present in real life, and in the media. I had already been thinking about how Clarissa's distance from Sally in later years might contribute to why she saw Sally in such a rosy light, but I really liked how you used Peter's pocket knife as an concrete example of this mindset in Clarissa - she thought about it fondly right up until Peter was actually there with the pocket knife, and then she switched to being annoyed about it. However, I think Clarissa still did genuinely feel more positive emotions towards Sally than towards either Peter or Richard, because Clarissa seems to be pretty honest to herself about how she feels towards certain people, she doesn't delude herself (much) - even having not seen Peter for a while, she was able to acknowledge things about him that pissed her, and she realizes that she doesn't really feel much for Richard, but we never see any instances of that with Sally.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I definitely think that what you said about romanticizing the past affects the way Clarissa sees Sally, but I think it's hard to know exactly how much. Like what would she think of Sally if she saw her now for example. And about Peter, although Clarissa said a lot of positive things about him, I feel like even before she saw him she still showed annoyance with his flaws, for example about having to share everything with him or the comments he made about her future. However, I still think it's really interesting that you applied these two points about human psychology to the book, and I do think they help reveal a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that Clarissa probably romanticized some aspects of Sally and her relationship with her - after all, few humans can be quite as perfect, exciting, beautiful, etc as she thinks of Sally, and I'm sure that the rareness with which she sees her in person could certainly contribute. As well as that, your point about how Clarissa valued the things about Sally which she cannot have in her own life is an interesting idea and definitely has some truth to it, though I interpreted it less as being attracted to opposite traits, but more so to the freeing life she could have with Sally, so she more so wants to be like her rather than just finding her cool or attractive. Lastly, I also have a song which come to mind when reading about Clarissa and Sally - check out the lyrics to Jenny by Studio Killers (quite a different vibe from your choice).

    ReplyDelete
  4. You make some great points here that could explain Clarissa's attraction to Sally. However, I honestly think that Clarissa really did love Sally but wasn't given the context to understand those feelings. The biggest difference between Clarissa's feelings for Peter and Richard and her feelings for Sally is their strength. Even if she is brushing over the uglier moments of their relationship because of how long ago they were, she feels so much more towards Sally than she does towards Richard, or even Peter. Furthermore, the strength of their relationship is corroborated by Peter, who notes how close Sally and Clarissa were. I do agree with you though about one reason why Clarissa finds Sally so attractive, which is her daring attitude and unique personality. Overall, this is a really great post!
    And while we're giving song recommendations, this topic reminds me of Younger by Ruel (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AiQiEiAPvUw). Ruel has another song that gives me Peter vibes (and how he's constantly denying being obsessed with Clarissa still) called Not Thinkin' Bout You (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wLzBdhH3sEw).

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think you are right about the romanticizing part for the most part. However, I think memories mainly reflect the emotions you feel around a person whether negative or positive. If you are always angry at a person when you see them, you will remember your anger over any positive emotions you felt in their presence unless you want to remember the positives more for some reason. As for Clarissa's feelings for Sally, I thought they were truer than they were with Peter and Richard. Even Clarissa herself described her relationship with Sally as purer than her relationships with men. She describes her relationship with Sally with a kind of certainty, whereas she describes her relationship with Peter and Richard as kind of unclear, you don't really get to truly understand how she feels about them (a lot of what we think we know is based on educated guesses and our assumptions). Even after all these years, Clarissa's kiss with Sally is the most exquisite moment of her life, not a moment with Peter or Richard. If you choose to believe this memory is romanticized, it carries significantly less weight, but I think it still matters. After all, you claim most memories are romanticized, so the fact that this is so important to Clarissa, even when compared with other romanticized memories, shows how much she cares about Sally.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts